Health

BMI Myths: What Your BMI Can and Can’t Tell You

Quick answer: BMI (body mass index) is weight in kg divided by height in metres squared. It is a quick screening tool, not a diagnosis. It doesn’t measure body fat directly, can misjudge muscular people, and Indians may face health risks at lower BMI than global cut-offs suggest. Use it together with waist size and a doctor’s check-up.

BMI is printed on health reports, gym forms and insurance applications. It is simple, which is why it is popular, and also why it is often misunderstood.

How is BMI calculated?

BMI = weight (kg) ÷ [height (m) × height (m)]

Example: 70 kg and 1.70 m tall → 70 ÷ (1.70 × 1.70) = 70 ÷ 2.89 = 24.2

[Calculator: BMI Calculator — get your BMI in seconds]

What are the BMI ranges for Indians?

Many Indian health guidelines use lower cut-offs than the global WHO ranges, because South Asians tend to carry more body fat and develop diabetes and heart disease at lower BMI.

CategoryWHO (global)Indian guidelines (adults)
UnderweightBelow 18.5Below 18
Normal18.5–24.918–22.9
Overweight25–29.923–24.9
Obese30 and above25 and above

So the person in our example, with a BMI of 24.2, is “normal” on the WHO scale but “overweight” by Indian guidelines.

6 common BMI myths

Myth 1: “BMI measures body fat.”

Fact: BMI only uses weight and height. Two people with the same BMI can have very different amounts of fat and muscle.

Myth 2: “A normal BMI means I am healthy.”

Fact: People with a normal BMI can still carry risky fat around the belly, have high blood sugar or high blood pressure. This is common in India and is sometimes called being “thin outside, fat inside.”

Myth 3: “A high BMI always means unhealthy.”

Fact: Athletes and people with a lot of muscle can have a high BMI with low body fat. BMI can’t tell muscle from fat.

Myth 4: “BMI works the same for everyone.”

Fact: It is less accurate for older adults (who lose muscle), pregnant women, and children and teens, who need age- and sex-specific BMI charts.

Myth 5: “I should aim for the lowest BMI possible.”

Fact: Being underweight carries risks too, including weaker immunity, low bone density and nutritional deficiencies. The goal is a healthy range, not the smallest number.

Myth 6: “BMI is useless.”

Fact: It is a helpful, free first check for large groups and for spotting trends over time. It just shouldn’t be the only measure.

What should you check along with BMI?

MeasureWhy it helpsIndian guidance (adults)
Waist circumferenceShows belly fat linked to diabetes and heart riskHigher risk above about 90 cm (men) or 80 cm (women)
Blood pressureHeart and kidney riskCheck at least once a year
Fasting blood sugar / HbA1cDiabetes riskCheck regularly after 30, or earlier with family history
Lipid profileCholesterol and heart riskAs advised by your doctor

Key takeaways

  • BMI = kg ÷ m²; it is a screening tool, not a diagnosis.
  • Indian guidelines treat 23+ as overweight and 25+ as obese.
  • Always pair BMI with waist size and basic blood tests.
  • Talk to a doctor before making big changes to diet or exercise.

FAQs

What is a healthy BMI for Indians?

Indian guidelines consider about 18–22.9 a normal range for adults.

Is BMI accurate for women?

The formula is the same, but women naturally carry more body fat at the same BMI. Waist size adds useful context.

Can I use the adult BMI chart for my child?

No. Children and teens need BMI-for-age charts. Ask your paediatrician.

How often should I check my BMI?

Every few months is enough. Daily changes in weight are mostly water and don’t mean much.

[Related: Diwali Air Pollution: 9 Ways to Protect Your Family] · [Related: Simple Tips to Protect Your Teeth and Gums]

Disclaimer: This article is general health information, not medical advice. Speak to a doctor for advice about your weight and health.